Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
-
- *** V3M DONOR ***
- Posts: 9361
- Joined: 29 Jan 2004 04:20 am
- Location: Nottingham, UK
Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Howdy all,
Could I ask you to fill in the attached poll please?
As you may well be aware, the standard pressed steel diff cover plate on all manual 300 series models is of questionable quality. They're pretty prone to rusting through, basically, and once bent (at all) they're very difficult to get flat. In a word, they're a pain in the arse. Some time ago, Mac expertly made a prototype, which we've given to a foundry to get an idea of costs.
We should be getting indicative costings back from Chris' foundry contact tomorrow. If we want to do it, we either have to hit the "GO" button on Tuesday (yes, one day later...), or wait for months. Long story...
The new cover plate will be cast aluminium, milled flat, and generally full of booyah! It will be a quality piece, and Mac's prototype looks amazing. Unfortunately, I don't seem to be able to find a pic just now. I'm considering advising 300 series owners on the direction of Mac's house, so they can bow in his direction several times a day. His contribution to the 300 series scene is pretty huge.
A quick decision will have to be made...so when the figures come back, we need to be able to work out if it'll be viable. We won't be ripping anyone off by selling them for more than we have to...but we need to be able to cover the costs. If it's going to cost £100, but people will only pay £25, we will have to abandon the plan.
So here's the deal: how much would you be willing to pay - if necessary - for a diff cover plate?
I'm willing to front the money, as long as a) I'm actually going to get it back in a reasonable timescale, and b) I can make a little bit of beer money for my trouble. We're talking about a substantial amount of money here, so forgive me if I'm a little mercenary about this. I appriciate it's a community project, with input from various parties, so I don't want to take the piss...but I still need to make this work for myself, financially, if I'm going to do it. I think it's also going to be a lot easier to administer this way. Getting help from the VOC in a hurry just isn't going to happen. I will try to give George Mitchell (Friends of the Volvo 300) a call tomorrow to see how he's going, but I think he would want to quiz his membership first. I hope you appriciate what I mean by all that. I'm not trying to rip (or piss) anyone off...but this is essentially going to be done on a commercial basis, so I need to put a commercial hat on.
Anyway...vote away, and we'll see if this is going to be viable.
cheers
James
Could I ask you to fill in the attached poll please?
As you may well be aware, the standard pressed steel diff cover plate on all manual 300 series models is of questionable quality. They're pretty prone to rusting through, basically, and once bent (at all) they're very difficult to get flat. In a word, they're a pain in the arse. Some time ago, Mac expertly made a prototype, which we've given to a foundry to get an idea of costs.
We should be getting indicative costings back from Chris' foundry contact tomorrow. If we want to do it, we either have to hit the "GO" button on Tuesday (yes, one day later...), or wait for months. Long story...
The new cover plate will be cast aluminium, milled flat, and generally full of booyah! It will be a quality piece, and Mac's prototype looks amazing. Unfortunately, I don't seem to be able to find a pic just now. I'm considering advising 300 series owners on the direction of Mac's house, so they can bow in his direction several times a day. His contribution to the 300 series scene is pretty huge.
A quick decision will have to be made...so when the figures come back, we need to be able to work out if it'll be viable. We won't be ripping anyone off by selling them for more than we have to...but we need to be able to cover the costs. If it's going to cost £100, but people will only pay £25, we will have to abandon the plan.
So here's the deal: how much would you be willing to pay - if necessary - for a diff cover plate?
I'm willing to front the money, as long as a) I'm actually going to get it back in a reasonable timescale, and b) I can make a little bit of beer money for my trouble. We're talking about a substantial amount of money here, so forgive me if I'm a little mercenary about this. I appriciate it's a community project, with input from various parties, so I don't want to take the piss...but I still need to make this work for myself, financially, if I'm going to do it. I think it's also going to be a lot easier to administer this way. Getting help from the VOC in a hurry just isn't going to happen. I will try to give George Mitchell (Friends of the Volvo 300) a call tomorrow to see how he's going, but I think he would want to quiz his membership first. I hope you appriciate what I mean by all that. I'm not trying to rip (or piss) anyone off...but this is essentially going to be done on a commercial basis, so I need to put a commercial hat on.
Anyway...vote away, and we'll see if this is going to be viable.
cheers
James
VOC 300-series Register Keeper
'89 740 Turbo Intercooler
'88 360 Turbo Intercooler
'85 360 GLT
'81 343 GLS R-Sport
'79 343 DL
'70 164
...and some modern FWD nonsense to get me to work...
'89 740 Turbo Intercooler
'88 360 Turbo Intercooler
'85 360 GLT
'81 343 GLS R-Sport
'79 343 DL
'70 164
...and some modern FWD nonsense to get me to work...
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
I also can't find any pictures currently... lame.
Right, to give all a heads up. Mac made a prototype cover plate when he was setting up his super diff gasket scheme. It's a really well thought out piece, and a lot stronger than the original. It would be cast in ali, a material that is more brittle than the pressed tin, however Mac has added strengthening ribs around, and the plate is thicker than standard so the only problem I can see here is with white roading (white as I think I'm the only one stupid enough to do this shouldn't be an issue) It certainly won't warp like the original did.
If this goes ahead, both me and the foundry want to make sure that these work properly and therefore, in true barley pickers style, want a "proper job". As cast ali shrinks by roughly 1.5% on cooldown if we used Macs original the bolt holes would be roughly 2/3mm out on pitch radially which isnt good enough... the whole point here is to stop leaks. So, Mac's plate will go to the pattern makers who also will be sent technical drawings (again provided by Mac in the main part) so that the flange is perfect. This will give us enough for the raw castings, which on completion will have the flange milled flat, and depending on the technique used bolt holes milled too.
I'm doing everything I can to reduce workload at the pattern makers and foundry to reduce setup costs here, and we need to know if this is going to work out. I wrote to George last week, but Foggy ringing him tonight is a great idea.
Please guys, opinions at this point are essential
Right, to give all a heads up. Mac made a prototype cover plate when he was setting up his super diff gasket scheme. It's a really well thought out piece, and a lot stronger than the original. It would be cast in ali, a material that is more brittle than the pressed tin, however Mac has added strengthening ribs around, and the plate is thicker than standard so the only problem I can see here is with white roading (white as I think I'm the only one stupid enough to do this shouldn't be an issue) It certainly won't warp like the original did.
If this goes ahead, both me and the foundry want to make sure that these work properly and therefore, in true barley pickers style, want a "proper job". As cast ali shrinks by roughly 1.5% on cooldown if we used Macs original the bolt holes would be roughly 2/3mm out on pitch radially which isnt good enough... the whole point here is to stop leaks. So, Mac's plate will go to the pattern makers who also will be sent technical drawings (again provided by Mac in the main part) so that the flange is perfect. This will give us enough for the raw castings, which on completion will have the flange milled flat, and depending on the technique used bolt holes milled too.
I'm doing everything I can to reduce workload at the pattern makers and foundry to reduce setup costs here, and we need to know if this is going to work out. I wrote to George last week, but Foggy ringing him tonight is a great idea.
Please guys, opinions at this point are essential
'89(G) 340 GLE B172k
'03 S60 D5 SE, '91 (J) MX5, 1954 Cyclemaster
Ex:
'89(F) 340 GL F7R (ex B172k) - Fake -> SBKV 300 Runner Up 08, 12; '91(H) 340 GL B14.4E - Kar; '88(F) 360 GLT B200E - Jet -> BKV 300 Runner Up 09; '89(G) 360 GLT B200E - Beast
'03 S60 D5 SE, '91 (J) MX5, 1954 Cyclemaster
Ex:
'89(F) 340 GL F7R (ex B172k) - Fake -> SBKV 300 Runner Up 08, 12; '91(H) 340 GL B14.4E - Kar; '88(F) 360 GLT B200E - Jet -> BKV 300 Runner Up 09; '89(G) 360 GLT B200E - Beast
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Pix, Pix, Pix.
My head is now so large I can no longer get through my workshop door. Thanks guys!
Chris is absolutely right - my prototype was never intended as a casting buck but rather as a full size "what it would look like". It was made to exactly fit my gasket jig - which itself is made from a diff casing. The thickness of the cover was designed to take M8x20mm setscrews rather than the std M8x12 (naturally I would supply the correct option in my gasket kits) Before producing anything the prototype must be remade to account for shrinkage in the mould. I would suggest that no holes are cast but rather the bolt holes and filler plug hole be jig drilled afterwards. Also worth considering is a thread insert for the filler plug rather than direct tapping in the alloy. The breather passage could be cast in and cleaned up afterwards - the breather port was designed to accept a piece of resized 15mm copper tube (split and soldered) to (from memory) 13mm which would then accept the original breather box.
A large headed old fart.
My head is now so large I can no longer get through my workshop door. Thanks guys!
Chris is absolutely right - my prototype was never intended as a casting buck but rather as a full size "what it would look like". It was made to exactly fit my gasket jig - which itself is made from a diff casing. The thickness of the cover was designed to take M8x20mm setscrews rather than the std M8x12 (naturally I would supply the correct option in my gasket kits) Before producing anything the prototype must be remade to account for shrinkage in the mould. I would suggest that no holes are cast but rather the bolt holes and filler plug hole be jig drilled afterwards. Also worth considering is a thread insert for the filler plug rather than direct tapping in the alloy. The breather passage could be cast in and cleaned up afterwards - the breather port was designed to accept a piece of resized 15mm copper tube (split and soldered) to (from memory) 13mm which would then accept the original breather box.
A large headed old fart.
88 5door Redline 1.7 52k - 19 XC60 Momentum Pro D4 AWD 17k
1950 pair of legs that don't work very well.
1950 pair of legs that don't work very well.
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Im trying to in-vision where this bit is? is it located on the back of the diff? Is the original really that weak? as my 5 speed is sitting in its arse in the shed and im woried it will of been bent outta shape now
Cheers Dan
p.s the prototype looks so much better then the original, great work Mac, and great work Chris and James for getting this thing rolling.
Cheers Dan
p.s the prototype looks so much better then the original, great work Mac, and great work Chris and James for getting this thing rolling.
-
- *** V3M DONOR ***
- Posts: 2693
- Joined: 12 Sep 2006 09:07 pm
- Location: Sunderland, Ringpiece Of England
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Now that's engineering! I think I'd pay 'whatever' for one of those, but might not be able to afford 3 any more, I have to buy a clio engine every month these days you know.
'87 Nissan Sunny
'95 945 LPT
'90 340 3dr
'87 360 GLT
'87 765 TIC
'75 Manta A
'70 Rover P5 V8
'67 MGB GT
'62 amazon 2dr
'95 945 LPT
'90 340 3dr
'87 360 GLT
'87 765 TIC
'75 Manta A
'70 Rover P5 V8
'67 MGB GT
'62 amazon 2dr
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Postage to here is probably quite a lot, so can't choose option which I would choose if I would live in there, so it is in lowest category for me, sorry
-
- Website Admin
- Posts: 2260
- Joined: 29 Dec 2003 01:33 am
- Location: Country of Duvel beer > Belgium <
- Contact:
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
That "new design" plate is just wonderful, far much better than the genuine one...
Collection: '78 343 Black Beauty, '82 345 GLS, '83 340 DL 2.0, '84 340 DL vario, '88 360 GLT 5d (2x) & 4d (2x), '89 GLT, '91 340 vario
Dad's cars: '87 340 vario, '89 340 vario
Lot of donors cars and parts...
V3M for life!
Dad's cars: '87 340 vario, '89 340 vario
Lot of donors cars and parts...
V3M for life!
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
It's also looking quite cost prohibitive I'm afraid to say guys. We have decided that after waiting 5 years without having a new diff cover, we'd be silly to rush this. Luckily, there are several backup plans (which are running as we speak) so will keep you informed!
'89(G) 340 GLE B172k
'03 S60 D5 SE, '91 (J) MX5, 1954 Cyclemaster
Ex:
'89(F) 340 GL F7R (ex B172k) - Fake -> SBKV 300 Runner Up 08, 12; '91(H) 340 GL B14.4E - Kar; '88(F) 360 GLT B200E - Jet -> BKV 300 Runner Up 09; '89(G) 360 GLT B200E - Beast
'03 S60 D5 SE, '91 (J) MX5, 1954 Cyclemaster
Ex:
'89(F) 340 GL F7R (ex B172k) - Fake -> SBKV 300 Runner Up 08, 12; '91(H) 340 GL B14.4E - Kar; '88(F) 360 GLT B200E - Jet -> BKV 300 Runner Up 09; '89(G) 360 GLT B200E - Beast
-
- *** V3M DONOR ***
- Posts: 5461
- Joined: 25 Apr 2005 06:52 pm
- Location: Anglesey North Wales
- Contact:
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
only 8 years gone by
Dai
Please email me directly on dai@classicswede.co.uk
http://www.classicswede.com
phone/text 07824887160
Web shop http://www.classicswede.co.uk/
Please email me directly on dai@classicswede.co.uk
http://www.classicswede.com
phone/text 07824887160
Web shop http://www.classicswede.co.uk/
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Does it add any mechanical strength to the diff? I assume not since its a soft gasket.
You could 3D print it these days. For plastic it would need a thicker section for the bolt areas + longer bolts but I don't think it would need machined.. or worse case metal sintered. Would just be a case of getting oil compatible material.
Is there a 3D model available?
Once you have the stl its very easy to chose material and a cloup print service with a few clicks. Gives you the price straight away.
You could 3D print it these days. For plastic it would need a thicker section for the bolt areas + longer bolts but I don't think it would need machined.. or worse case metal sintered. Would just be a case of getting oil compatible material.
Is there a 3D model available?
Once you have the stl its very easy to chose material and a cloup print service with a few clicks. Gives you the price straight away.
1980 345 DL_______1987 360 GLE (project car restored to GLT spec and B230FT'd)
1984 360 GLT______1987 360 GLT
1983 360 GLS______1989 360 GLE
1985 340 GL_______1986 340 1.4
1985 360 GLS______1995 940 SE 2.3 Turbo Estate (daily)
1987 340 GL 1.7
1984 360 GLT______1987 360 GLT
1983 360 GLS______1989 360 GLE
1985 340 GL_______1986 340 1.4
1985 360 GLS______1995 940 SE 2.3 Turbo Estate (daily)
1987 340 GL 1.7
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Id've thought not either - it's only very thin plate... nowadays 3D Printing one of these is probably the best way forward!
1989 - Volvo 360 GLT
1985 - Volvo 360 GLS
2008 - Volvo S60 SE Lux
1985 - Volvo 360 GLS
2008 - Volvo S60 SE Lux
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Sorry to dredge up an old thread, just wondering if anything further happened on this ?
Very interesting about the casting proposal, and I see there were 'backup' plans mentioned.
Even if a small run was made, with a higher price, I am sure they would sell to those who want to make genuine improvements to their car i.e like myself
Very interesting about the casting proposal, and I see there were 'backup' plans mentioned.
Even if a small run was made, with a higher price, I am sure they would sell to those who want to make genuine improvements to their car i.e like myself
1987 360 GLT
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Unfortunately I don't think the project progressed past prototype stages, though it is possible to still find decent diff cover plates if yours has been damaged/corroded. Worth checking, sometimes people carelessly jack the car up on the diff and crush the lip of the coverplate. In some circumstances they've been known to rust through too.
1989 - Volvo 360 GLT
1985 - Volvo 360 GLS
2008 - Volvo S60 SE Lux
1985 - Volvo 360 GLS
2008 - Volvo S60 SE Lux
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
Thanks Steve.
Looked to have the makings of a great upgrade/replacement project.
My cover is weeping a little, the plan was to source a good spare to refurbish/rustproof ready to fit with a new gasket kit when I came to do the job. I would then refurb my original cover as a good spare.
I ordered a 'used' cover along with a new gasket kit from a well known parts site, but the cover that turned up is only fit for the scrap bin.... Still waiting on a response from the vendor and still looking for a good spare cover....!
Looked to have the makings of a great upgrade/replacement project.
My cover is weeping a little, the plan was to source a good spare to refurbish/rustproof ready to fit with a new gasket kit when I came to do the job. I would then refurb my original cover as a good spare.
I ordered a 'used' cover along with a new gasket kit from a well known parts site, but the cover that turned up is only fit for the scrap bin.... Still waiting on a response from the vendor and still looking for a good spare cover....!
1987 360 GLT
Re: Urgent opinions required: Diff cover plates
I was wondering does yours leak from the edge or is it rusted through? If the latter then I agree that it's only fit for scrap. Instead if its a bit bent at the edges it's probably as good as any replacements you will find now.
1988 340 1.4 GL, 218k, 5 door (Grey Bess). Gone to CBA.
1991 340 1.7 GL, 64k, 5 door, petrol blue (Deep Blue).
1988 360 2.0 GLE, 140k, 5 door, ocean blue metallic (Blue Bess).
1989 340 1.7 GL, 108k, 3 door (Red Ness).
More info here!
1991 340 1.7 GL, 64k, 5 door, petrol blue (Deep Blue).
1988 360 2.0 GLE, 140k, 5 door, ocean blue metallic (Blue Bess).
1989 340 1.7 GL, 108k, 3 door (Red Ness).
More info here!