off topic

A global place for general discussion (Volvo, V3M or non-Volvo related topics).
Please introduce yourself here, your Volvo 300 hobby...
NO technical support, parts requests or car advertisements here
Post Reply
redline
*** V3M DONOR ***
Posts: 5432
Joined: 05 Oct 2004 10:18 am
Location: MILTON KEYNES , ENGLAND

off topic

Post by redline »

ok , there has been a lot of discussion lately about threads going off topic and yes the December meet thread turning into a potted history of the BX 16 valve is a prime example.




reading through the threads it is amazing how many do go off topic from one degree to another , and how innocently it happens.( I must admit that myself and Foggy are probably the worst at this ),
its natural really and we must not get too anal over it ,
but how many times does a face to face conversation go on and off of the origional topic life would be very boring and cold if it didnt.

Usually it starts by some one making a comment that has some off topic content and others responding to that comment ,either in fun or often asking a genuine question( if irrelevant to the original thread ) and then the original thread gets lost in the friendly banter or genuine interest shown .

for example the december meet thread .

the whole thing started due to Petes comment about not wanting fwd french tat in pictures ,,fair comment

I replied jokingly and then foggy commented and another member asked a genuine question

so apart from the fact the whole sorry affair is FARRELLS fault :lol:
it goes to show how easily it can happen .

now the whole thread is being consumed with comments about thread jacking !!!

what I suggest is ( and it wont be easy ) if you want to ask something that could lead to a thread going off tangent,


do it in the general forum with a very clear title and then perhaps post a link to that thread in the thread that made you think of it
does that make any sense at all ?

a link to a fresh thread is likely to be far less a distraction

I also feel we need an area where we can chat about anything and personally I would still like a joke forum as well

overbore has got the balance just right but then again it isn't a one marque forum like this one

http://www.overbore.co.uk/forum/

people who want to just talk about cars dont use the lounge

just as

people who dont want to have a laugh dont visit overbores sandpit simple as that

yes this is a forum about the 300 series volvo but there are other things on the planet worth talking about so lets try not to be so anal and a bit more accepting of other peoples views.

in the christmas meet thread I said something like

I think part of the success of V3M it is the fact that this is far more than a forum about one make of car,

but a place where friendships are made and kept.

please dont prove me wrong
Image
User avatar
Ricatron
Posts: 173
Joined: 26 Sep 2007 04:59 pm
Location: Manchester

Post by Ricatron »

that was a big rant redline!

im a big fan of having a section of just pub talk or something along those lines?

we cant help a bit of banter on the theads its all good fun unless it distroys the real reason for the thread. i understand why we have mods and they have to keep to a level. tough job.

a section for randomness would just increase how good the forum is.
we can add such things as our other cars etc?

what do the mods think?

this is not to slate the forum as i do spend some good time on it :D
i mention before that i am a mod on another forum but i dont have mod rights (thankfully) im the forum designer. who does the design on this forum? its very nice, most forums look a bit rough when this one is very professional.

can we discuss a randon section of the forum?
Image
1979 yellow 343
redline
*** V3M DONOR ***
Posts: 5432
Joined: 05 Oct 2004 10:18 am
Location: MILTON KEYNES , ENGLAND

Post by redline »

I didnt mean it to come over as a rant as a proposed solution to an ongoing problem .

this is a great forum, the continued membership growth proves that beyond all doubt.

and I for one am very proud of how its developed and grown ,
when I joined just over 3 years ago there were only 153 members.
look at it now

I wouldent hang around here if I didnt enjoy the camaradary ,
I wouldent have organised two of the earlier meets and tried to arrange two others since , I wouldent have bothered to get the original batch of url stickers organised or halped Dave with the calling cards.

I just feel there is more to it than just the great little car which brought us all together.
Image
User avatar
Ricatron
Posts: 173
Joined: 26 Sep 2007 04:59 pm
Location: Manchester

Post by Ricatron »

its all in the name of fun we just need a funnies section to release our non topic needs :)
Image
1979 yellow 343
Post Reply